There are a lot of feelings about Lillian Daniels’ new memoir and about my previous post about it. Feelings are important. I titled my post “Read This Book Unless You Can’t” and I meant that. I wasn’t promoting the book for everyone. But frankly it was a helpful read for me to process my own experiences. Maybe I should have called that post “Read This Book Unless You Can’t or You Won’t.” Anger and pain continue to simmer when someone we know to be a @$%! continues to be tolerated much less respected by people who don’t know what we know.
There are things I know about certain colleagues that make me want to poke my eyes out especially when I learn that they just got a sweet promotion or they got a slap on the wrist for something that broke the hearts of countless innocent people into shards. And so I share this link from United Church of Christ leaders. They are asking for:
A new fitness review of Rev. Lillian Daniel.
A new process of repentance and repair to be engaged for and by the author.
The author to remove the book from circulation.
I’m grateful we serve a church that tries to hold people accountable. I especially love this part of the letter’s introduction:
We encourage people to act from their ethical and spiritual obligations.
This was the point of my last post. We all have spiritual obligations. Some of us are obliged to sit with the outcast. Some of us are obliged to sit with the victims. Some of us are obliged to hold colleagues accountable. Some of us are obliged to keep confidences. Some of us are obliged to preach hard truths. Some of us are obliged to offer compensation to victims. This is Church. We can always do better. And I apologize if I gave you the impression that offenders should not be held accountable much less benefit from their misconduct. Knowing what I know now (that LD self-published her book against the wishes of the victim) I agree that it should be removed from circulation or all proceeds should go to the victim.
Lillian Daniel’s new memoir about being a self-described “bad pastor” is hot right now. Her writing is dependably exquisite whether she’s detailing stories of ministry or explaining how to paint a fence. Actually she’s never written about fence painting as far as I know, but her books are always bestsellers in Church World.
This is not a book review. It’s a pastoral plea – or something like that.
Like me, Rev. Dr. Daniel served in parish ministry serving one congregation at a time for many years, and then she shifted to Mid-Council Ministry overseeing many congregations in a specific geographic region. In her case, she is the leader of The Michigan Conference of the United Church of Christ. I retired from a position like this in the Presbyterian Church USA in March. I loved it. I think she also loves her newish call.
As a parish Pastor, I dealt with a variety of issues involving parishioners that occasionally required some form of disciplinary consequences as they impacted the congregation I served. As a Mid-Council Leader, I dealt with the same issues but they specifically involved a pastor or some other congregational staff member.
In my denomination’s disciplinary process, the board of elders (the Session) deals with misconduct involving congregants. The corporate bishop (the Presbytery) deals with misconduct involving Clergy and Christian Educators. Although our system is not perfect, I was grateful for it as I read Daniel’s account of her own disciplinary experience. She was accused of sexual misconduct involving a church staff member in 2015. It was terrible. All of it.
As a Mid-Council Leader, if accusations were made public that a clergyperson had been found guilty of some form of misconduct (professional, financial, sexual) I would receive angry phone calls from people reminding me that we Christians believe in grace. “Where is the forgiveness?” some would ask. “This is not even a big deal,” they might say not knowing the details.
Here comes my pastoral plea:
Yes, we who hope to follow Jesus are about redemption and grace. In fact, the Rules of Discipline in our denomination’s Constitution opens with these words:
The power that Jesus Christ has vested in his Church, a power manifested in the exercise of church discipline, is one for building up the body of Christ, not for destroying it, for redeeming, not for punishing. It should be exercised as a dispensation of mercy and not of wrath, so that the great ends of the Church may be achieved, that all children of God may be presented faultless in the day of Christ.
The whole point of “discipline” in the Presbyterian Church U.S.A. is to build up not break down. We are not about destroying each other – although sometimes we are woefully destructive. I thank God for the many times the Presbyteries I served did it well.
When someone is found guilty of misconduct and it’s publicly announced, it is essential that the accused has a circle of support. From the depths of someone’s embarrassment, shame, and humiliation I thank God when there are people who remind them that through Jesus Christ we are forgiven. Kyrie Eleison all day long. I’m grateful for those who reach out to offer support, to pray, get together for lunch, invite them to worship with the congregation they serve. This is holy work.
God is with us no matter what and some of us are called to sit with people in the depths of their regret and pain.
Also there are other people who cannot and should not be the ones who offer these reminders of graceto the accused . Not now. Maybe not ever, needing to separate themselves for their own survival.
There are the victims most directly harmed by the misconduct and then there are the other layers of victims who feel morally wounded. Their hearts are broken. Their souls are troubled to the point of paralysis. Those who admired and depended on the accused feel like they never knew them. Maybe they know devastating details that cannot be shared. The resulting detritus caused by misconduct can impact relationships beyond easy repair.
Again, those found guilty of misconduct need a team to dry their tears and hear their confession. They need spiritual direction and counseling and – again – reminders of grace.
And – again – some of us cannot be on that team. It doesn’t feel safe. Maybe it’s not safe.
There are so many things about Lillian Daniel’s book that I like. And there are other things she doesn’t seem to understand, but then again this is her experience. Sometimes it seems like the guilty bounce back more quickly than the layers of victims (primary, secondary, tertiary, quaternary, and even those far outside the Church who will use this story to point to yet another reason why Christians are hypocrites.) The guilty are often required to process their actions so it happens very intentionally. Victims might need a longer time to process their pain.
Some of us leave Church if we have committed some shameful act. Or we leave because we’re so disillusioned by the shameful acts of our leaders. Lillian Daniel doesn’t leave:
“The memories and scars we carry from one church experience follow us to another. While I don’t love those memories, I am grateful for them. They allow me to relate to the outsiders who are still seeking something from the church today.”
“The most important person in the church is the one who has not yet arrived.”
There’s a discussion guide in the back of this book that looks essential to our own personal processing. Most of us have experienced disappointments and shame and grace. I hope you will read the book about Lillian Daniel’s experience – unless you just can’t.
Skye Perryman coined the term “courage is the new currency.”
And while she is involved in political and legal matters in hopes of bolstering democracy, this term is an excellent mission statement for people of faith. The same day I heard Perryman’s term for the first time, I read this article by our favorite graph creator Ryan Burge who has rightly declared that the Presbyterian Church U.S.A. – the largest Presbyterian denomination in the nation- is about to hit a difficult milestone.
He declares what many of us have known for decades: that this once-esteemed denomination is on the cusp of falling below one million members. We PCUSA church people who once prided ourselves in having over three million members in the 1980s – the second largest Mainline Denomination – are now outnumbered by Missouri Synod Lutherans, Jehovah’s Witnesses and Seventh Day Adventists.
We Presbyterians pride ourselves in sharing our form of government with the authors of the Constitution, of whom twelve of the 56 signers were Presbyterian. We also claim among our Reformed and Always Reforming siblings eight U.S. Presidents (not counting Donald Trump who has actually never been Presbyterian), George Pullman, Andrew Mellon, George Armour, Sam Walton, Fred Rogers, and Condoleezza Rice. It used to be true that civic and business leaders throughout the United States claimed to be Presbyterian Christians. Yay for us.
And then things changed. The narrative is that things started to go south for the largest Presbyterian denomination when our leaders started to meddle in issues like segregation and unjust wars. Some say that we became too political, and specifically that we became too politically liberal. I see it another way.
While Constantinian Christianity was the norm in the early part of the 20th Century in the United States, there were courageous Christians who said, “Wait a minute. Some of the things our nation is doing are in no way aligned with the teachings of Jesus.” Cue people like Jerry Falwell, James Dobson, and Tim LaHaye who literally broadcast a Christian belief system that aligned with a specific political agenda. To be “Christian” meant being homophobic, anti-immigrant, complementarian in gender roles and maybe a little racist. To be a “good Christian” was equated with being a politically conservative citizen.
Lots of Presbyterians in my denomination left. They started more conservative Presbyterian denominations. They joined non-denominational congregations. They became Southern Baptists. Or they just left the Church altogether. And yet, many who stayed in the PCUSA were trying to be courageous, speaking up for People of Color, LGBTQ folks, and others who were previously not at home in the Mainline Church.
Yes, this is incredibly simplistic. And yet, we Mainline Presbyterians (and United Methodists, Evangelical Lutherans, Episcopalians, Disciples of Christ, Progressive Baptist, etc.) now find ourselves in a season when Christians who previously voted for the red team apparently voted for the blue team recently. Do yourself a favor and read The Donkey and Jesus by Kimberly Winston.
In many places and in many families, it’s still courageous to say that you voted for candidates who campaigned on “Love Thy Neighbor” rather than the candidates who campaigned on “if they can’t afford high beef prices, they should pick another protein.” The courage to quote Chapter 25 of The Gospel of Matthew became the new currency. Check out this article too.
It is true for all People of Faith – Christians, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, Sikhs – that the truest understanding of our belief system involves loving our neighbors. It is a spiritual creed to say that we are less concerned with left vs. right than we are concerned with up vs. down. The Bible is an equal opportunity offender, politically speaking. But Jesus’ constant message was that we are to be concerned with those who are “down.”
It takes courage to be the one child who defends another child being taunted. It takes courage to be the worker who stands up to an immoral boss. It takes courage to preach prophetically. It takes courage to tell the truth. It takes courage to know the truth about ourselves. But courage is – at least today – an increasingly valuable currency.
Final note: Here is an opportunity to show courage if you happen to live in the Northern Virginia, Suburban Maryland or DC area. There is a public hearing in support of Major Jason Watson who stood on the steps of the U.S. Capitol Building in August calling for “the impeachment, conviction, and removal of President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance, criticizing administration policies including military actions in Venezuela, Cuba, and Iran, as well as immigration and First Amendment concerns.”
The public hearing is on Tuesday, November 17 at Joint Base Anacostia-Bolling, Washington, D.C* and the purpose is to ask for the release of Major Watson prior to his trial. He has been in solitary confinement since his arrest “for crowding and obstructing the Capitol steps and making contemptuous remarks under Article 88 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice.”
While he may or may not be guilty of these charges, Major Watson is a 2005 graduate of the U.S. Air Force Academy and a recipient of the Defense Meritorious Service Medal. It’s not all that courageous for me to stand up for someone who doesn’t deserve solitary confinement for this accusation, but I hope to do so.
*Because this public hearing is on a military base, please contact his attorneys via Monument Legal to ask for access.
Some large church pastors are called to specific roles like administration or family ministry or outreach into the community. It’s essential for congregations to understand that – in larger congregations – all the pastors don’t do all the things. (i.e. Don’t criticize the Associate Pastor for not teaching any Bible studies if their job description doesn’t include leading Bible studies.)
For a solo pastor or a generalist associate pastor – not to mention a Head of Staff pastor – the responsibilities are overwhelming. And yet the expectation is that these particular pastors actually try to do all the things:
Sermon preparation
Worship leadership
Hospital and other pastoral care
Office administration
Spiritual counseling
Teaching the Bible and theology
Officiating at weddings, funerals, baptisms
Moderating meetings
Mentoring
Strategic planning
Local engagement
Faith development
Staff and volunteer supervision
Day to day operations
Officer and staff training
Local engagement
Addressing walk-in emergencies
Sometimes a new pastor is asked to spend more time on administration because “our last pastor was a great preacher who couldn’t manage the details of running an organization.” Or maybe the last pastor was very active out in the community, but now the congregation needs someone to address the crumbling steeple and how to raise money for a new one. But no matter what, every pastor has a primary job that tops all others. We are called to love our people.
Years ago lots of clergywomen like me were connected via RevGalBlogPals, a network of bloggers in ministry. One of them – my colleague and an amazing pastor/mid-council leader – Sarah Sanderson-Doughty – wrote a blog called You’ve Really Got to Love Your People. She now posts here.
Sarah is a leader who – like other excellent leaders – knows what’s essential in serving a community of human beings. You’ve got to love your people. When they are in trouble, you stand with them even though they are middle-aged and your role involves youth ministry. When they are sick, you pray with them even though your purview is global mission. When they are on the cusp of eternity, you hold their hand in hospice even though pastoral care is not what you were called to offer.
You’ve got to love your people. And who are our people, Pastors? They are obviously the members and friends of our congregations. They are possibly former members of our congregations. They are possibly the former pastor of our congregations. They are possibly the other clergy in town. They are possibly the strangers who drop by in need of food. They are possibly the agnostic friends whose kids play sports with our kids. They are possibly members – like you – of the PTA or the community choir or the garden club but they aren’t members of any spiritual community.
Truth: no one can humanly be available to all people all the time. For the sake of our limited bandwidth/mental health, we need to prioritize how we spend our time. We need to respect boundaries. We need to comply with our job descriptions. We need to abide by social norms. What I’m not talking about here: inserting ourselves into situations where we aren’t wanted or needed. What I’m not talking about: at home visits for everybody.
Another truth though: Church members and friends won’t remember all the sermons or Bible studies. They won’t remember how well we prepared all the holiday bulletins. They won’t remember how efficiently we dealt with the broken HVAC system or the delicate personnel matter. But they will remember that – when they needed us – we were warm and comforting and welcoming. They will remember that we loved them.
Maya Angelou said it best: “I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.”
At my mother’s graveside almost 40 years ago, a cousin came up to me and said, “You know the Bible says that you can’t be a pastor.” This seriously happened. How deeply did she believe she had to correct my theology that she would offer it at my mother’s graveside?
Years later at the wedding of one of our children with quite a few Muslim relatives and friends present, someone pulled me aside and asked, “How can you be sure the bride’s (relative) is not a terrorist?” This seriously happened. How deeply did he believe that he had to ask that he would do so at a wedding?
There is serious ignorance in our country especially about what Muslims believe. For what it’s worth, there is also serious ignorance in our country about what Christians believe.
Over 25 years ago, I was at the first graduation of Computer CORE – the hugely successful nonprofit started by Fairlington Presbyterian Church in Alexandria, Virginia that trains adults in computer skills towards certification equipping them to find good jobs with medical benefits. Most of the graduates were (and still are) immigrants.
There was a young graduate who was following me around surreptitiously taking photos of me all night. I finally asked him – a young man from Morocco – why he was taking my picture and he was embarrassed. But he said that he was taking pictures of me to send to his family in Morocco.
“When I told my family that I was taking classes in a Christian Church, my parents were terrified. They told me I needed to get out of there because Christians want to kill Muslims. But I wanted to send them a picture of the pastor of the church that didn’t want to kill me; those Christians were trying to save my life.”
Thanks be to God. Computer CORE remains the most impactful ministry I have ever been connected to, changing the lives of thousands of people since 1999.
Many Muslims do not understand what Christians believe according to what the Bible says. Many Christians do not understand what Muslims believe according to what the Quran says. If you saw those “on the street” interviews with regular Americans before the elections, you heard some of the misinformation being shared about Muslims:
They want to impose sharia law. Actually Sharia is the word for a Muslim’s daily spiritual habits like how to pray, what to eat (halal), how to share with neighbors (zakat.) It’s comparable to a Jew’s spiritual practices (eating kosher) or a Christian’s spiritual practices (daily prayer).
I will never wear a burka! Great. Don’t wear one. Nobody is pursuing that practice even for Muslim women in the United States because it’s unconstitutional. Wearing a burka is an expression of faith that reflects a desire for modesty and piety. My favorite way to explain why some women wear a burka or an hijab or a khimar is from Diana Butler Bass who – when her young daughter asked why someone was dressed like that after 9-11 – explained that it was that woman’s way to love God. (Source.) It’s similar to the headwear worn by Amish women and men or the habit worn by nuns.
They are taking over!Not even close. And frankly, while Christianity is the majority faith in the United States, we Christians could stand to practice our faith more faithfully.
A wise person recently told me that people only know what they know. The best way to know is to do the research, observe in close personal proximity, be curious, connect with people who do not look or live or pray like we do. We don’t learn by making assumptions, devouring biased media, or listening to people who don’t know what they are talking about.
I don’t believe that “all religions are the same.” They aren’t. Islam and Christianity are not the same. But I believe that Muslims and Christians and all people of every faith and no faith are created in God’s Image (whether they believe that or not.) We are called to love each other and love involves knowing our Muslim neighbors. If we don’t think we have Muslim neighbors, do some research. Women: join a book group. Or read on our own.
The global neighborhood is changing and maybe our local neighborhoods are changing. Instead of complaining about this, maybe God is offering us an opportunity.
[Note: I’ve been reading Shea Watts’ new book on the influences of Contemporary Christian Music on Christian Nationalism and it’s a short but dense account of a relationship that is particularly timely for these days. Shea is a friend who has experienced some deconstruction himself. He and Brandon Lake served together at Seacoast Church a while back. Shea is now an ordained PCUSA pastor. Read his book.]
My social media algorithm apparently thinks I’m interested in people who are in the throes of deconstructing their faith. (The algorithm is correct.)
My feed is filled with people who call themselves ex-evangelicals and/or former Christians including Sarah Paige (a 30-something pastor’s daughter), Jen Hatmaker (a writer and podcaster who started Austin New Church with her former husband in 2008), Rachel Kesler (former evangelical, now Episcopal priest and Kenyon professor), Todd Phillips (former megachurch pastor now calling himself an atheist/agnostic), and Joseph Yoo (South Korean-American Pastor’s Kid and former evangelical, now an Episcopal priest serving Mosaic Church in Texas.) This was part of Rachel Held Evans’ story. This is Bart Ehrman’s story.
My own faith was informed by a treasured array of Christian leaders. I grew up in a mainline Presbyterian family in a university town. My confirmation teachers included Alan Keith-Lucas and Bernard Boyd. I was active in Young Life in high school and my “Campaigners” Bible Study leader was a college student named Nora Tubbs. (So lucky/drenched in grace/#blessed.) I attended The Chapel Hill Bible Church in college led by Jim Abrahamson, a graduate of Dallas Theological Seminary. Grant Wacker was one of my college professors. I’ve hung out with Brian McLaren and Diana Butler Bass. I once drove all the way to Grandville, Michigan to hear Rob Bell preach. I frankly do not agree with all the things that all these smart people believe. They are not God.
I believe that it’s not only okay to grapple with our faith; it’s essential – because none of the world’s best preachers/teachers/thinkers are God. Bad things happen when we conflate our spiritual leaders with the Creator. I will never watch this movie.
And I feel sick when I read the comments of those who have watched that movie, along with tens of thousands of others whose trauma was inflicted by church leaders. Many have understandably chucked all church rituals, participation in spiritual community, and any semblance of faith.
I have not. My theology continues to shift and shift back and shift forward again. I am not afraid of questions or doubts. And yet, after over 40 years of being a professional minister, it’s tricky finding “a new church” in retirement. I’m experiencing church everywhere and I have my new neighborhood (and God) to thank for that. You Church People already know what I miss about Church and what I will never miss.
After all these years, I’m not worried about “the rapture” or whether or not Mary was a virgin. (Do I believe God can make a virgin pregnant? Sure, but my faith doesn’t depend on it.) I increasingly understand the historical Jesus as a Jewish man of a certain time and place who – yes – was also the perfect living Word of God. Jesus spoke in parables because he was a rabbi after all (if you have rabbi friends you already know that many questions are explained with a parable) and so I see many Hebrew stories as parables. I taught children in church that “parables are the SHOCKING (slap both hands to your cheeks) stories Jesus taught us to explain how much God loves us.” That would also be true for the parable of Jonah and the Big Fish.
I don’t care whether or not Judas died by hanging or by flinging himself off a cliff. That wasn’t the point of the stories.
I do care that millions of people who claim to be Christian bear no resemblance to Jesus in their words, behaviors, or priorities. And this is destroying the Church of Jesus Christ dramatically more than “culture war” issues. I care that I am personally clueless about life’s realities all too often and I am a lazy pray-er about that.
I really, really care that we elect honorable people next week to lead our towns and states and nation. Just as my own family includes people I love who were raised in traditions that are not Christian, I know that God uses people of every faith and no faith to show us the way of peace and hope. I believe that some of our best spiritual leaders happen to be the very people we condemn. (although God loves them and they might be God’s favorites.)
How your are deconstructing your own faith – whatever that faith might be? And please don’t tell me that your belief system hasn’t changed since you were in the second grade. I hope that’s not true because I will be so judgy about it.
Read Shea’s book. It’s especially good when you get to the part about Charlie Kirk’s funeral.
I’ve deeply appreciated Yancey Strickler since he wrote This Could Be Our Future. I spend a lot of my life/brain pondering what the future Church might look like and he broadens my perspective.
The institutional Church makes me crazy and it also gives me hope because I believe that 1) we humans are a hot mess and 2) God is unspeakably gracious.
The Future Church looks like a lot of things both ancient and new and/or something we cannot yet imagine. What I know for certain is that relationships between human beings will continue to feed souls, inspire goodwill, and heal broken hearts in spite of our tendencies.
I received this article in my inbox this morning and will be thinking about it for a long time. I hope you will too.
THE BREAKING OF THE WORLD by Yancey Strickler
What happens when the things that make you a good friend become products machines deliver?
Will we talk less to each other and more to software programmed to sound like us, but owned by companies with their own interests to serve?
Does it matter if the shoulder you’re crying on belongs to a company?
AI is breaking the world from what it has been to what it is becoming.
I’ve spent much of my adult life at keyboards, interacting and building things for others in the digital world AI is now remaking. But increasingly I feel meaninglessness in what I once believed in.
I feel like a racecar driver in a world of driverless cars. A good direction giver in an age of Google Maps. An engaged conversationalist, but not one who catalogues and saves every part of a conversation to be reused and combined later into actionable insights.
These skills matter to me. They’re part of who I am. But I can feel their place in the world diminishing as the intricacies of life move from the world of humans into the world of machines.
I don’t want to stop needing other people and I don’t want other people to stop needing me. A good conversation doesn’t need to be saved and actionable to matter. It’s about another person choosing to be there for you. The next time it might be you that’s there for them.
From the perspective of the companies selling this software, these are problems to commercialize and solve. But these “inefficiencies” are the little things that thread the texture of life.
“You are the product,” went the 2010s saying. Now it’s more: we’re the raw material, too. The writing, images, conversations, and accumulated knowledge we put online became training data for machines built to produce their own versions of us. Only always on, always there, and for pay.
In a Hacker News discussion about a recent batch of proposed mathematical proofs published by OpenAI, a commenter who had worked on one of the problems for 24 years writes:
“I don’t know what to think exactly. I spent thousands of hours on that problem. I really enjoyed it. Hearing that it is solved somehow makes me sad in a far-off way, like hearing an ex-girlfriend died suddenly in a car crash. I don’t know, there’s probably a lot of people feeling odd emotions tonight.”
I recognize this odd emotional state. For me, it shows up as loss of trust. Because digital media is now so easy to produce and so hard to verify, all forms of digital expression feel less valuable to me than they did two years ago. I’m less open, more suspicious. When I encounter something interesting online, my first instinct is no longer to share it. Now I doubt whether it’s real.
The state of things has changed my output too. I’ve delayed sending this piece for more than a month, and there’s another piece that’s been sitting in my drafts folder even longer. Why add to the noise when so little feels honest and true?
A single decision to replace original creative work with generated work can seem harmless. But as more people do it — when the rate of what’s published follows the rate of what can be generated — we might discover that we can say everything there is to say, but no one wants to hear it anymore. Our attention and belief the next victims of a tragedy of the commons.
It doesn’t take everyone doing it for this to happen.
Would I give up AI to go back to how things were before?
100%. Not even a question.
I understand why someone with an enormous investment in these machines wants them to keep going. I get the attraction of being first as a founder. Race conditions are hard to escape. But those are incentives, not destinies.
“It’s amazing how much we are willing to change everything without having any idea what’s going to happen afterwards,” mathematician Terence Tao said in a talk recently. “It’s insane, the pace. And there’s no reason to be this fast. No reason at all.”
People describe AI as inevitable. Like a storm approaching on the horizon. But this isn’t the weather. These are decisions being made by a small number of people. What to build, how quickly to release it, what risks to take. Beneath it all, the promise of AGI calls: an apple offering total and complete knowledge.
But once we take that first bite, can we ever return to the garden?
I fear what gets destroyed on the way there. Livelihoods, skills, relationships, a reason to call someone. Our agency, our abilities, and our independence could very well diminish as we become more dependent on always-on machines and less on each other and ourselves.
In past eras workers destroyed industrial equipment to slow the rate of change. But today’s Luddites also have a factory in their pocket that makes their personal lives and spreading their ideas easier. Can you oppose the machinery at work while making the most of it at home?
What’s my individual responsibility then? Should I boycott AI? How and where do we draw the lines? Should that mean hiring a human programmer even when using a coding agent would be cheaper? What are we saving now, and what might it cost us later? How are we supposed to weigh these choices in a world where not everyone will?
I do use these tools to augment my work and I’m still creating my own rules for how I use them in ways that protect my practice.
I’ve started with some personal choices: I don’t want to use AI in place of a human relationship. I’m careful about what I share and give access to. I observe AI sabbaths — days entirely away from the models with room for my own thoughts and the people closest to me. I’m committed to keeping up the practices that help me figure out what I feel and think, and to using AI mainly to spot blind spots and handle logistics of projects already in motion.
A quick litmus test: am I using AI to avoid a conversation, hand over a decision, or skip something it would be more meaningful for me to develop on my own? If it’s just logistics, I’ll prompt away. But if any of those other things are involved, I’ve learned to pause.
Personal choices like these don’t settle the bigger questions. The fact that some of us use these tools doesn’t mean we chose the world that seems to be coming with them. The people who live through this do not all have the same power to shape it.
This is how the world we know breaks. Not with a bang. Not with a whimper. With a payoff.
Just like yesterday’s post, today’s post is informed by The New York Times article by Christopher Marquis “Let’s Abolish Business Schools.” I hope you’ll read it. I’m interested in the differences between business schools and divinity schools/seminaries (which are legion.)
Harvard Business School famously uses case studies as their “signature method of business education.” I would love to see this method used with Master of Divinity students. The difference though – between how a business school uses case studies and how a seminary might use case studies – is important. According to Marquis, the HBS method tends to seek a particular response, albeit after lively discussion and analysis. He notes that this is problematic though. A single response “narrows . . . imagination.” A single response seems to be a roadblock for a “yes and” answer to the problem.
Professor Marquis writes that “case studies end up as instruments of reputation management.” I can attest to the fact that discerning God’s will and then acting accordingly in professional ministry can damage a pastor’s reputation, at least among the most powerful players in a congregation.
“Complexity is systematically shaved away and dissenting voices often go unheard. Real organizations don’t move in clearly delineated phases toward a decision point but business school teaching materials often do – compressing timelines, dropping messy subplots and smoothing over contradictions to produce clean narrative arcs and satisfying problems to debate.” Amen to that.
Case studies for seminarians would ideally involve not pretending to be the person in charge (like a CEO) but practicing collaborative ministry where there are not “winners and losers” as much as there is an expansion of the Reign of God. Yes, please.
I could write these all day, based upon my personal experiences after 42 years in professional ministry, but you’d never believe they could be real. As we’ve all said, “I can’t make this stuff up” but in order to protect the innocent (and the guilty) I’m making these case studies up.
You are the solo pastor of a medium sized congregation with a part-time secretary, a part-time music minister, a part-time nursery attendant and a seminarian working 5-10 hours a week while finishing their last year of study. There are nine elders who make decisions with the pastor and staff. The seminarian has befriended a barista in town who is gay and the barista asks the seminarian if they can use the church sanctuary to marry their partner. The seminarian (erroneously) tells the barista that “they don’t do gay weddings” and the word gets around the town (population 10,000) that First Church on the Hill – known for their welcoming spirit and community service – will not allow the beloved barista and their partner to marry in their church building. In the meantime, the barista who is not part of any congregation, is in a terrible car accident and the partner (also not part of any congregation) is terrified. They share a four year old child with special needs and a dog. An Open and Affirming organization the next town over has sent protesters to gather on Sunday mornings in front of First Church on the Hill and they are very angry that this church won’t allow this wedding especially considering that the barista is in the hospital and maybe the couple wants a hospital room ceremony. The board of elders is meeting tonight to discuss this situation. How does the church respond? Who does what? What makes Jesus happy?
You are the Associate Pastor of a 400 member congregation who officiated at a wedding last weekend. It was clear that The Bride’s family and The Groom’s family strongly dislike each other. There is unfortunate sniping all wedding weekend and the couple was happy to leave town on their brief honeymoon. The Head of Staff is on a mission trip to Haiti. Two days after the newlyweds return from their honeymoon, there is a gas explosion in their rental home (owned by a parishioner) and they are both killed. Their families must return to town from other states to plan a joint funeral. The Head of Staff isn’t due back for another week. The bride’s family wants to sue the parishioner who was their landlord. The groom’s family wants their son buried in a family plot across the country. The bride’s family wants both the bride and groom cremated together. The groom’s family wants a cut of the bride’s trust fund. How does the church respond? Who does what? What makes Jesus happy?
The first year in your new call as Head of Staff in a large church is going well. There is plenty of funding to serve the neighborhood and beyond. The staff gets along well. There are new people joining the congregation. People seem responsive to your leadership. An elder who is a five-generation member takes you out to lunch and let’s you know that his family has long supported every pastor for over 200 years and they have shared their financial successes from a family business generously. They continue to do so. The elder informs you that he has some expectations based on his family’s legacy and he looks forward to working with you for many years. A month later as you are getting the lay of the financial land, you notice a fund named after the elder’s family and you ask the church treasurer about it. Clearly, no one is supposed to ask questions regarding this fund. But you were a financial analyst before going to divinity school and it looks like the esteemed family is laundering money through the church. The church treasurer, it turns out, is the second (out of three) spouses of the elder’s son and she is very protective of the family. There are also three other members of that family serving crucial positions in the congregation. The church’s gym is named for this family. And a cousin in the family was just featured on Crimes Gone Viral after being exposed with a second family in Omaha where she has often traveled for work since the corporate headquarters of her branch of the family business is there. How does the church respond? Who does what? What makes Jesus happy?
The point of a class called “Ministering Through Minefields” would obviously not be about finding answers for every particular, complicated church problem. It would be how to be how to faithfully do improv in Church World taking into account the polity and theology of the congregation. Tell me this wouldn’t be a helpful class. Possible instructors: Commission on Ministry Moderators.
This article by Christopher Marquis, Professor at the University of Cambridge Business School inferentially explains why we need divinity schools and seminaries (by explaining why MBA programs are ruining our culture) and it also speaks to our overall broken system.
Please read the article, especially if you are affiliated with a seminary or divinity school and/or you care about the future of professional ministry, the Church, and the direction of our world.
The first divinity schools were established to prepare future preachers by training them in a liberal arts curriculum including history, ancient languages, scriptural interpretation, pastoral care, and systematic theology while also participating in some form of field education. Previously, a young man (and they were always men) might finish his formal education (possibly just grammar school) and then apprentice alongside an established clergyman without specific teaching in Greek and Hebrew, history, etc. Wealthier men would attend college, study the classics and then apprentice with a seasoned pastor.
People ostensibly wanted to become pastors so that they could lead in the proclamation of the gospel for the salvation of humankind, bolster the shelter, nurture and spiritual fellowship of the children of God, lead in the maintenance of divine worship, work towards the preservation of the Truth, and shepherd the promotion of social righteousness and the exhibition of the Reign of Heaven to the world. (My PCUSA siblings will recognize that wording.) Nobody was in it for the money.
[Note: Some denominations – or non-denominations – do not require formal education for their clergy today, and it shows. Going out on a limb here but I believe that most theological abuses are a result of uneducated but charismatic clergy who preach according to a naive or false understanding of Holy Scripture. 2 Chronicles 7:14 – which is a favorite verse among Christian Nationalists – is not about the United States as The New Israel, for example.]
Professor Marquis notes that we have medical schools to prepare people who wish to improve the physical and mental health of human beings. We have law schools to prepare people who wish to serve justice. Along the same lines, we have divinity schools and seminaries to prepare people to serve the spiritual needs of all people.
But business schools – perhaps first created to prepare people who hope to manage people for the benefit of a healthy and prosperous economy – now serve to promote themselves and make the most money possible for those at the top of the ladder. (ouch)
“The modern business school is designed to promote dealmaking, simplification and optimization. Business-educated elites increasingly populate political leadership, bringing with them a transactional view of public life. One investigation found that of 45 current heads of state who had studied in the United States, 10 were business majors, and six of those also earned M.B.A.s President Trump, a Wharton graduate, has created foreign policy and government itself as extensions of dealmaking and personal gain.”
Our system is broken.
Instead of learning for the sake of learning, we now grade college degrees based on how much money the degree holder will make four years after graduation. Congratulations to Duke math majors.
This is not to say that all students headed to business schools are greedy, self-promoting Scrooges. But Professor Marquis writes: “Again and again, I have watched students abandon their altruistic intentions, instead becoming consumed by whether to choose careers in consulting or finance and who will land a summer internship at McKinsey or Goldman Sachs.” (Note to my friends who are McKinsey or Goldman alums: I still love you even though you have at least two homes.)
So . . . back to why we absolutely need divinity schools and seminaries: While it’s clearly counter cultural to want to create authentic community by sharing the message of God’s generous and loving will for the universe without much regard for personal power-building, that goal is more necessary than ever. Each of the complex problems of the world are a result of our focus on personal gain (what can I get out of this?) rather than concern for our neighbors.
Seriously, can you name a single global issue that is not connected ultimately to human selfishness? Homelessness, famine, war, professional misconduct, hunger, climate change, false imprisonment, the humongous divide between the haves and have nots?
And it could get worse before it gets better. Liberal Arts Majors will be ineligible for federal student loans if their universities cannot show that those studying music, English, sociology, etc. can earn more than mere high school graduates. This is unbelievably short-sighted. Carly Fiorina (medieval history and philosophy major) became the CEO of Hewlett-Packard. Jack Ma (English major) is the co-founder of Alibaba. Howard Schultz (communications major) was the CEO of Starbucks. Arundhati Bhattacharya (English literature major) became chair of the First Bank of India.
And most of us know that seminary/div school graduates are among the lowest paid workers with graduate degrees. According to salary.com:
Entry-Level (1–3 years, youth ministers, associate roles, or starting chaplains): $35,000 to $47,000 per year.
Middle Half (Median range across all experience levels): $48,260 to $76,640 per year.
Senior-Level / Experienced Pastors & Specialized Roles (8+ years, senior pastors, or specific master’s concentrations like missions or counseling): $70,000 to $117,000+ per year.
Top 10% Earners: $98,890 to $135,000+ per year
Yes, we love the LORD but we also have bills to pay – including graduate school loan repayments.
Nevertheless – nevertheless – we need more people equipped to share the deep meaning of holy scriptures, to know how to sit with people in grief and personal crisis, to grapple with the meaning of life in community, to serve the vulnerable because of cosmic mandates (not just to feel good). We need spiritual leaders who do not cause harm because they know that – actually – the Bible does not condemn LGBTQA people or refer to modern-day abortion or teach that women are to be controlled by men. They’ve read the Bible in ancient languages in light of context and history. They’ve had boundary training (no, you can’t use the church credit card for your own groceries or sleep with the choir director.) They’ve had training to address everyday racism. They’ve had additional training in non-profit management or transitional ministry or public speaking.
God’s people deserve leaders who are well-trained and theologically focused for the sake of God and the world, rather than the sake of personal ladder-climbing. Also, the institutional Church is changing and it’s energizing, rather than exhausting to consider making the necessary culture shifts.
A final word from Professor Marquis: “abolishing business schools cannot mean abandoning the people in them. The goal is not to write off the students as aspiring selfish capitalists; it is to stop funneling them through a machine that narrows their sense of possibility.” It’s about the people. How can we best serve the people?
The less you know, the better you sleep. Russian Saying
I was in Montgomery on a Civil Rights tour in March 2023 with Denise and several other PCUSA Mid-Council Leaders – specifically in the breakfast buffet line of our hotel – when my phone rang. It was our daughter – TBC – who shared what she’d just heard from another friend. “Evan has been kidnapped in Russia,” she said. Just at that moment, his picture came up on the huge TV screen in the dining room with the headline: “Russia Arrests Wall Street Journal Reporter Evan Gershkovich on Spying Charges.” I was still on the phone with TBC and said, “Actually, it looks like he’s been arrested.”
TBC had met him through a Bowdoin friend and it reminded me why I had loved living in Northern Virginia. Often the national news was our local news. There’d be a national news report about a special meeting in Yuma or an attack on a U.S. military base and I would have heard about it from a church person or a soccer parent before it was public knowledge. It made national and global news feel more personal.
It was also international news when Evan was released on August 1, 2024 in a 24 person swap including the U.S. prisoner Paul Whelan. Evan had been imprisoned falsely for 491 days before his release.
I call him “Evan” even though I don’t know him. But I felt sick imagining what he and his parents were going through. My own children were his age. It felt like he could have been one of my own.
Read his book. Not only is it an excellent report of what happened before, during and after his detention; it also reminds us that what we are experiencing in our own country is familiar in Putin’s Russia.
When Putin attacked Ukraine, his plan was to “demilitarize and denazify” them.
Putin called the leaders of Ukraine “drug-addled” telling Ukrainians to stop listening to them.
In casual conversations with Russian locals, during the course of a single period of time, Evan met a woman who said, “Ukrainians would never forgive our country,” another Russian who said “Ukrainians got what they deserve for provoking Moscow,” and another man who “preferred not to think too hard.” “It’s none of my business,” the man said, “The less you know, the better you sleep.” We live among realists, deniers, and the indifferent.
Evan writes, “The government had criminalized the spread of what it called ‘fake news’ about its armed forces and imposed a penalty of up to ten years in prison.”
While Evan and other reporters saw what was going on, many Russians continued to go about their everyday lives. “It feelsstrange, seeing all these people go about their lives, like nothing’s going on,” he said to a friend. “You’ll get used to it,” she replied.
Sound familiar? I’m not saying we in the United States have succumbed to the levels of propaganda and fearfulness that happen under Putin but every day, anyone who’s paying attention will recognize that our leaders demonize and mischaracterize their enemies. Our leaders threaten those who protest the injustices we can see with our own eyes. OR we know people who prefer not to think about it. We have become accustomed to many of our friends and family acting as if nothing unconstitutional is going on.
Read this book. It’s not only an excellent read; it helps explain what’s going on in our world right now – both in Russia and in the United States. And then, please vote for candidates who refuse to spread lies and deception.